A contemporary article considers the people and preparation behind RNLI lifeboat rescues.
1A lifeboat rescue may begin with a pager sounding while someone is at work, with
2family or asleep. Across the United Kingdom and Ireland, RNLI crews can be
3called out at any hour. Most crew members are volunteers. Their readiness is
4supported by regular training, both on the water and on land. When a request for
5help arrives, the coastguard contacts the station's operations manager or launch
6authority; a decision to launch must be made before the crew are paged.
7The people who put to sea are only part of that response. Shore crew help to
8launch and recover the lifeboat and make it ready for another call. Depending on
9the station, preparations can involve opening doors, clearing a slipway or
10getting launching equipment ready. Boat crew prepare their protective kit while
11others prepare the means of departure. The visible movement towards the water
12depends on work that is less likely to appear in a photograph.
13Training gives this divided work a common direction. A volunteer must learn more
14than the position of a rope or the operation of a piece of equipment. Practice
15allows people to develop reliable actions, communicate and understand their
16responsibilities. Exercises on shore and afloat are therefore part of
17lifesaving, even when nobody is being rescued. The quiet session without a crowd
18has value because a later emergency may allow little time for explanation.
19Preparation makes cooperation possible.
20None of this removes danger. A lifeboat operates in an environment that cannot
21be ordered to become calm. Information must be gathered, a crew assembled and a
22judgement made about the response. Courage is needed, but courage does not mean
23ignoring everything that could go wrong. A decision has consequences for
24rescuers as well as for the people waiting for help. The strength of an
25organised service lies partly in making responsibility something that is shared
26rather than simply admired.
27The launch is the sharp edge of a much longer effort. Behind it lie repeated
28exercises, checked equipment and tasks completed when the sea has attracted no
29headlines. A single successful action can catch the eye; the patient work that
30makes it possible slips out of sight. Yet readiness is not a heroic possession
31that one person keeps in a pocket. It is a net of dependable actions. Pull away
32the unnoticed strands and the impressive moment has less to rest on.
33Public recognition often prefers a face to a system. One portrait gives a story
34a centre, while a list of roles can seem less memorable. That does not make
35individual bravery unimportant. A particular decision may deserve particular
36praise. But a rescue described only through its most striking figure leaves
37something out. The person aboard the boat belongs to a larger group of people
38whose contributions differ in visibility, not necessarily in worth. Recognition
39becomes fairer when it can hold both ideas at once.
40The work also reaches beyond the station. The RNLI is a charity, and public
41support helps provide boats, equipment and training. Those resources connect
42people who may never meet. A donation, a training session and a prepared
43launching system are different contributions, but all belong to the same
44practical purpose. The link is not made by applause alone. It has to be
45maintained through the less spectacular business of supporting people and making
46sure that a service can continue to respond.
47A better account of lifesaving would therefore look at the whole chain, without
48pretending that every link does the same job. It would notice the person who
49goes to sea and the person who helps bring the boat back. It would leave room
50for preparation as well as action, for judgement as well as daring. The most
51useful tribute to a rescue team is an understanding of what its members make
52possible together. The boat may leave the shore, but the effort that carries it
53does not end there.
Source B
In this nineteenth-century biographical account, Grace Darling and her father row towards people stranded after a shipwreck in 1838. A coble is a small fishing boat.
1It is said that Grace was the first to seize an oar, and spring into the boat;
2but her father, who was a brave man, quickly followed, and the two were soon
3working together in harmony. They scarcely spoke at first, William Darling only
4giving Grace a few directions with regard to the management of the boat, and
5then both used their utmost endeavours to propel her towards the desired spot.
6One moment we must linger to look at the heroic girl as she sits firmly in the
7boat, with a steady light in her eyes, lips firmly compressed, and strong brave
8heart. Could we have seen Grace Darling in more attractive guise? The thunderous
9waves were leaping and foaming around the little boat; the dark clouds were
10lowering, and the winds blowing furiously. The afrighted sea-birds looked at
11them, and screamed shrilly as they saw the boat rocked to and fro, now leaping
12on the top of a wave that tossed it high, and now sinking down, down, as if it
13were going to the very bottom of the deep. But Grace was not afraid. She
14scarcely thought of the danger; for her heart and sympathy were with those who
15were on the rock. Long before she got to them, her imagination pictured the
16patient faces, full of pain, which would grow bright when they saw her; and as
17she thought of them, her arm gained new strength, and she went on again more
18energetically than before. Was she, indeed, a girl? Had she sisters, who cried
19out if a pain touched them, and who were always helplessly appealing to men for
20help? Did she know what fear was? Yes; she knew that she would always be afraid
21of her own thoughts, if she did not what she could to rescue the shipwrecked
22strangers.
23On they went, over the stormy waters, every minute being nearer their goal. The
24foam dashed in the face of the intrepid girl, and the salt water made her eyes
25smart; but she did not relax her efforts, but kept nobly and steadily at her
26work. Her father could not but admire her courage; and the sight of it gave him
27even more determination to succeed.
28"Are you getting tired, my girl?" he asked presently.
29"Not very, father. We shall do it," she replied.
30"Yes, I really hope we shall. There they are, poor wretches, glad enough to see
31us, I know. It is a good thing it is an ebb tide. If it had not been, we could
32not have passed between the islands. It will be flowing when we come back; and
33if there are no sailors to help us, we may as well make up our minds to stay on
34the rocks with the others, for we shall not be able to get home again."
35"Do not let us meet trouble half-way, father; the sailors will be able to help
36us."
37They pulled hard a little longer, and then contrived to reach the rock on which
38the sufferers were waiting.
39"Pray, take care, Grace."
40"All right, father. Do not be afraid. I will not risk all by my mismanagement."
41"If the coble is beaten against the rocks, she will be smashed to pieces."
42"I will take care, father. Cannot you land now? See, there is a chance. Now,
43father!"
44With a tremendous effort, Darling got on the rock, and immediately Grace rowed
45the boat back so as to keep her afloat on the water, and free of the dangerous
46reefs.
Question 01 [4 marks]
Read again the first part of Source A, from lines 1 to 12.
Choose four statements below which are true.
Shade the circles inside the boxes beside the statements you think are true.
Select a maximum of four statements.
Cross out the whole box if you make a mistake.
To restore a statement you crossed out, draw a circle around that box.
A. Every RNLI crew member is paid to go on rescues.
B. RNLI crews may be called out at any hour.
C. Training takes place only on the water.
D. Shore crew help to launch and recover the lifeboat.
E. The crew are paged before any decision to launch is made.
F. Crew members train regularly on land as well as on the water.
G. Shore crew have no role in preparing for a later call.
H. A pager may sound while a crew member is asleep.
Question 02 [8 marks]
You need to refer to Source A and Source B for this question.
Both texts describe people setting out to save lives at sea.
What can you infer about the differences in the support available to the rescuers?
Question 03 [12 marks]
You now need to refer only to Source A, from lines 27 to 32.
How does the writer use language to show that unseen preparation is essential to a rescue?
Question 04 [16 marks]
For this question, you need to refer to the whole of Source A, together with the whole of Source B.
Compare how the writers convey their different feelings and perspectives about heroism.
In your answer, you could:
compare their different feelings and perspectives
comment on the methods the writers use to convey their feelings and perspectives
support your response with references to both texts.
Question 05 [40 marks]
“When someone achieves something remarkable, we focus too much on one hero and forget the team behind them.”
Write an article for your school or college website in which you argue your point of view on this statement.
Marking guidance
Question 1
Correct selections: B, D, F and H. Award one mark for each correct final choice, up to four. Lines 1–6 establish round-the-clock readiness, volunteers, training in both settings and the order of the launch decision and paging. Lines 7–12 establish the shore crew’s role in launch, recovery and later readiness.
No credit for A, C, E or G. These contradict the source. The task requires a maximum of four choices; for an overselected formal practice script, apply the centre’s current AQA marking instructions.
Question 2
This is an inference and synthesis question about support, not an analysis of language. Join relevant details from both sources and explain the differences they suggest.
Source A, lines 1–19, describes a service with a launch authority, trained crew, shore helpers and established preparation. Source B, lines 1–5 and 30–36, presents a father and daughter sharing the immediate rowing task, with uncertainty about whether sailors will be able to help them return. This can suggest an organised network available before departure compared with a small family partnership depending partly on help it has not yet reached.
Source A, lines 40–46, connects training and equipment to public support for a charity. Source B instead gives prominence to the father’s local knowledge of the tide and the daughter’s physical effort and confidence. Credit well-supported inferences about different forms of practical assistance, preparation or reliance on personal resources.
Do not infer that Grace had no relevant skill or that the modern rescuers face no danger. Neither source establishes that. Credit accurate alternatives.
Indicative bands: 1–2 marks for relevant information with little inference; 3–4 for some supported interpretation; 5–6 for clear inferences joining both texts; 7–8 for precise, insightful synthesis of differences with well-selected details. Award 0 for no relevant material. Judge quality, not a fixed number of comparisons.
Question 3
The opening metaphor presents the launch as the sharp edge of a much larger effort. Its contrast between an eye-catching action and patient work moves attention from the visible moment towards preparation.
The rejection of readiness as a possession in one person’s pocket challenges the idea of an isolated hero. The extended net image gives separate actions a shared strength; removing strands makes their importance easier to imagine.
Credit precise analysis of contrasts, sentence construction, metaphor or word choices that explains how preparation is presented as essential. Naming devices or paraphrasing the practical facts alone is not developed language analysis.
Indicative bands: 1–3 marks for basic comments linked to wording; 4–6 for some explained effects; 7–9 for clear, developed analysis using precise examples; 10–12 for insightful analysis of how the language makes unseen preparation indispensable. Award 0 for no relevant material.
Question 4
Source A values individual courage but argues that public recognition should also include preparation and less visible teamwork. Source B directs intense admiration towards Grace’s courage, compassion and physical endurance. Both texts show cooperation; a developed answer can recognise that shared ground while explaining differences in emphasis.
Source A moves from factual explanation of roles towards an argument about recognition. Its contrast between a face and a system, the net metaphor and the final chain image make collective contribution central. The writer’s concessions prevent the argument from dismissing individual bravery.
Source B invites the reader to pause over Grace’s appearance and imagined feelings. Emphatic praise, the violent movement of the sea and questions about gender magnify her exceptional qualities. The narrative combines danger with confidence, while dialogue about tides and the boat supplies practical difficulty. These choices encourage admiration for a particular person rather than an impersonal system.
Credit discussion of the historical writer’s assumptions about women, provided it is tied to the wording and perspective. Do not require pupils to agree with those assumptions. Do not erase the father’s role: the opening partnership and later practical directions qualify a simple lone-hero reading.
Indicative bands: 1–4 marks for simple relevant comparison; 5–8 for some explanation of perspectives and presentation; 9–12 for a clear, sustained comparison with explained methods; 13–16 for insightful, developed comparison integrating precise evidence and the effects of the writers’ choices. Award 0 for no relevant response. A single-source answer cannot demonstrate a developed comparison.
Question 5
Judge the writing as a persuasive article for a school or college audience. Accept any defensible position. Reward a developed argument about recognition, individual contribution and teamwork, with purposeful examples and awareness of objections. Pupils do not need to use either reading source; copying Source A’s argument does not replace developing their own response.
AO5, 24 marks: assess communication, audience, purpose, register, development and organisation. Indicative bands: 1–6, a simple or fragmentary position with limited development; 7–12, some shaped argument and audience awareness but uneven control; 13–18, clear, developed and persuasive writing with purposeful organisation; 19–24, an assured, engaging argument whose ideas and effects are controlled throughout.
AO6, 16 marks: assess sentences, grammar, punctuation and spelling independently. Indicative bands: 1–4, frequent errors and limited control; 5–8, some accurate patterns with variable security; 9–12, generally secure accuracy and a purposeful range of structures; 13–16, sustained technical control, flexible sentence choices and highly secure accuracy. Occasional slips do not automatically exclude the top band.
Award 0 in either assessment objective if there is no relevant evidence for it. Select a best-fit band and place the response within it. Do not allocate marks by counting techniques, paragraphs or impressive words. These original notes support classroom moderation; they are not an official standardised mark scheme.