An original contemporary article reflects on the achievements and everyday difficulties of railway travel.
1The train is on the display board, then it is not. A line of yellow letters
2changes, and the people on the platform look up together. The service has been
3cancelled. Nobody has moved, but every journey has altered. A student will miss
4a connection; someone will be late to open a shop; a parent begins calculating
5the cost of another bus. A railway timetable appears to describe trains. In
6practice, it also holds together the arrangements of other people's days.
7For the regular passenger, the pleasure of a journey is often simple: it happens
8as expected. A seat is useful, a clear announcement welcome, a working
9connection almost luxurious. There is beauty beyond the window, certainly, but
10it competes with a question on the traveller's phone: will I arrive when I said
11I would? The modern railway can carry us across a country while leaving us
12unsure about the last few miles. That uncertainty is a poor travelling
13companion.
14None of this means we should forget the achievement. Steel wheels follow a route
15through hills, over water and into crowded cities. From a moving carriage, a
16field becomes a brief green page, a river flashes silver and is gone, and
17distant houses arrange themselves into a village before slipping behind us. It
18is still extraordinary that a person can sit almost motionless while a landscape
19streams past. Familiarity has put a coat over the wonder. It has not removed it.
20But wonder cannot be the whole bargain. A passenger may admire the bridge and
21still need the lift at the station to work. Someone may enjoy the landscape and
22still need to know whether a ticket will be accepted on the replacement service.
23These are not small-minded complaints beside a grand achievement. They are the
24measures by which that achievement becomes available to ordinary people. A
25remarkable network is useful only when a person can actually use it.
26Information matters most when the plan breaks. Silence makes a platform longer.
27A vague promise of an update leaves passengers building little towers of
28guesswork: perhaps another train will come, perhaps the connection will wait,
29perhaps a different ticket is needed. Clear advice cannot undo every delay. It
30can stop a delay becoming a maze. Telling people what is known, what is not
31known and when they will hear more treats them as participants in a journey
32rather than objects stored beside a track.
33The workers facing that uncertainty deserve support too. An employee with no
34reliable information cannot manufacture an answer, however often the question is
35repeated. Anger directed at the nearest uniform rarely reaches the person who
36made the decision. A better service would give staff useful information and the
37means to pass it on. Courtesy is a shared obligation, but courtesy should not be
38used as a substitute for the practical tools needed to help people.
39What should we ask for, then? Not a promise that machinery will never fail or
40that weather will always cooperate. We should ask for a service that notices the
41consequences when things do go wrong. A missed connection, a closed help point
42or an inaccessible route is experienced by somebody with a destination, not by
43an abstract passenger total. The quality of the railway is tested in how it
44carries those people through the interruption as well as through the
45countryside.
46I would like us to keep both kinds of attention: the eye that sees a viaduct and
47marvels, and the eye that sees a stranded passenger and asks what can be done.
48Admiration and criticism belong on the same platform. We honour an invention by
49expecting it to serve the people who depend on it. The most impressive journey
50is not simply the one that moves fastest. It is the one whose passenger can
51trust that arriving matters as much as departing.
Source B
In a letter written in 1830, Fanny Kemble describes a trial journey with the railway engineer George Stephenson.
1We were introduced to the little engine which was to drag us along the rails.
2She (for they make these curious little fire-horses all mares) consisted of a
3boiler, a stove, a small platform, a bench, and behind the bench a barrel
4containing enough water to prevent her being thirsty for fifteen miles,—the
5whole machine not bigger than a common fire-engine. She goes upon two wheels,
6which are her feet, and are moved by bright steel legs called pistons; these are
7propelled by steam, and in proportion as more steam is applied to the upper
8extremities (the hip-joints, I suppose) of these pistons, the faster they move
9the wheels; and when it is desirable to diminish the speed, the steam, which
10unless suffered to escape would burst the boiler, evaporates through a
11safety-valve into the air.
12The reins, bit, and bridle of this wonderful beast is a small steel handle,
13which applies or withdraws the steam from its legs or pistons, so that a child
14might manage it. The coals, which are its oats, were under the bench, and there
15was a small glass tube affixed to the boiler, with water in it, which indicates
16by its fullness or emptiness when the creature wants water, which is immediately
17conveyed to it from its reservoirs. There is a chimney to the stove, but as they
18burn coke there is none of the dreadful black smoke which accompanies the
19progress of a steam vessel. This snorting little animal, which I felt rather
20inclined to pat, was then harnessed to our carriage, and, Mr. Stephenson having
21taken me on the bench of the engine with him, we started at about ten miles an
22hour.
23The steam-horse being ill adapted for going up and down hill, the road was kept
24at a certain level, and appeared sometimes to sink below the surface of the
25earth, and sometimes to rise above it. Almost at starting it was cut through the
26solid rock, which formed a wall on either side of it, about sixty feet high. You
27can't imagine how strange it seemed to be journeying on thus, without any
28visible cause of progress other than the magical machine, with its flying white
29breath and rhythmical, unvarying pace, between these rocky walls, which are
30already clothed with moss and ferns and grasses; and when I reflected that these
31great masses of stone had been cut asunder to allow our passage thus far below
32the surface of the earth, I felt as if no fairy tale was ever half so wonderful
33as what I saw.
34Bridges were thrown from side to side across the top of these cliffs, and the
35people looking down upon us from them seemed like pigmies standing in the sky. I
36must be more concise, though, or I shall want room. We were to go only fifteen
37miles, that distance being sufficient to show the speed of the engine, and to
38take us on to the most beautiful and wonderful object on the road. After
39proceeding through this rocky defile, we presently found ourselves raised upon
40embankments ten or twelve feet high; we then came to a moss, or swamp, of
41considerable extent, on which no human foot could tread without sinking, and yet
42it bore the road which bore us.
43This had been the great stumbling-block in the minds of the committee of the
44House of Commons; but Mr. Stephenson has succeeded in overcoming it. A
45foundation of hurdles, or, as he called it, basket-work, was thrown over the
46morass, and the interstices were filled with moss and other elastic matter. Upon
47this the clay and soil were laid down, and the road does float, for we passed
48over it at the rate of five and twenty miles an hour, and saw the stagnant swamp
49water trembling on the surface of the soil on either side of us. I hope you
50understand me. The embankment had gradually been rising higher and higher, and
51in one place, where the soil was not settled enough to form banks, Stephenson
52had constructed artificial ones of wood-work, over which the mounds of earth
53were heaped, for he said that though the wood-work would rot, before it did so
54the banks of earth which covered it would have been sufficiently consolidated to
55support the road.
Question 01 [4 marks]
Read again the first part of Source A, from lines 1 to 13.
Choose four statements below which are true.
Shade the circles inside the boxes beside the statements you think are true.
Select a maximum of four statements.
Cross out the whole box if you make a mistake.
To restore a statement you crossed out, draw a circle around that box.
A. A cancellation changes passengers’ plans.
B. The writer says the cancelled train is moving faster.
C. A parent considers the cost of another bus.
D. The writer thinks passengers never notice the landscape.
E. Regular passengers may value clear announcements.
F. The writer says a working connection is unwelcome.
G. The writer describes uncertainty as a poor companion.
H. All the passengers are travelling for leisure.
Question 02 [8 marks]
You need to refer to Source A and Source B for this question.
Both sources describe travelling by railway.
What can you infer about the differences between the travellers’ experiences of the railway in Source A and Source B?
Question 03 [12 marks]
You now need to refer only to Source A, from lines 26 to 32.
How does the writer use language to convey the frustration caused by unclear information?
Question 04 [16 marks]
For this question, you need to refer to the whole of Source A together with the whole of Source B.
Compare how the writers convey their different feelings and perspectives about railway travel.
In your answer, you could:
compare their different feelings and perspectives
comment on the methods the writers use to convey their feelings and perspectives
support your response with references to both texts.
Question 05 [40 marks]
“Reliable public transport would improve everyday life more than almost any other change to our local area.”
Write an article for a local news website in which you argue your point of view on this statement.
Marking guidance
Question 1
Correct statements: A, C, E, G. Award one mark for each correct selection.
For this practice paper, if more than four boxes remain selected, subtract one mark for each selection beyond four from the number of correct selections, with a minimum of zero. For example, four correct selections among five selected boxes earns 3 marks.
Question 2
Source A presents a familiar system on which people rely for daily commitments, so failure creates uncertainty and cost. Kemble encounters a new technology on a guided excursion and responds with excited curiosity.
The modern passenger may be physically still but mentally occupied with disrupted arrangements; Kemble’s movement becomes magical and her attention expands to engineering and landscape. Support inferences with details from both sources.
Do not reduce Source A to wholly negative or Kemble to wholly uncritical: the modern writer recognises wonder, while Kemble offers practical explanations of operation and construction. The question still asks for differences, supported by both texts. Apply AO1 bands for 8 marks.
Question 3
The paradox that silence makes a platform longer conveys a psychological stretching of waiting rather than a literal change.
The image of towers of guesswork suggests a fragile accumulation of assumptions. The repeated perhaps clauses enact repeated uncertainty and shifting plans.
The maze metaphor presents confusing information as an additional obstacle. The final opposition between participants and objects stored by a track criticises dehumanising treatment and appeals to dignity. Reward precise analysis within the range; apply AO2 bands for 12 marks.
Question 4
Compare the mixed modern perspective with Kemble’s delight rather than claiming a simple negative/positive opposition. Source A sets admiration beside a demand for reliable, inclusive service; Kemble expresses wonder at a developing invention and admiration for its engineering.
Source A moves between everyday examples, concession, imagery and direct questions to persuade. Kemble’s intimate address to a friend, explanatory detail, sustained animal metaphor and fairy-tale comparison convey excitement while making unfamiliar machinery understandable.
Both make the abstract achievement human: modern passengers’ obligations matter, while Kemble gives the engine bodily qualities and highlights Stephenson’s problem solving. Their endings value different measures of success: dependable arrival and the overcoming of physical obstacles. Credit alternative supported comparisons; apply AO3 bands for 16 marks.
Question 5
Mark the response as an independent piece of transactional writing addressed to the audience and purpose in the task. There is no required viewpoint and no need to repeat either source.
AO5, 24 marks: assess communication, audience, purpose, register, development and organisation. Indicative bands: 1–6, a simple or fragmentary position with limited development; 7–12, some shaped argument and audience awareness but uneven control; 13–18, clear, developed and persuasive writing with purposeful organisation; 19–24, an assured, engaging argument whose ideas and effects are controlled throughout.
AO6, 16 marks: assess sentences, grammar, punctuation and spelling independently. Indicative bands: 1–4, frequent errors and limited control; 5–8, some accurate patterns with variable security; 9–12, generally secure accuracy and a purposeful range of structures; 13–16, sustained technical control, flexible sentence choices and highly secure accuracy. Occasional slips do not automatically exclude the top band.
Award 0 in either assessment objective if there is no relevant evidence for it. Select a best-fit band and place the response within it. Do not allocate marks by counting techniques, paragraphs or impressive words. These original notes support classroom moderation; they are not an official standardised mark scheme.