An original contemporary opinion article considers what town centres should provide for people travelling after dark.
1A town does not become empty when its shops close. Cleaners are still at work
2behind the glass, a kitchen porter is waiting for a bus, and somebody is walking
3home from a late shift. The day has ended for some people, but not for everyone.
4Yet many town centres seem designed on the assumption that the last customer
5takes the last human need away. A shutter can close a business. It cannot close
6the lives around it.
7Look at the things a person can use without buying anything. A bench may be
8fenced off, the public toilets locked, the shelter occupied by an advertising
9display. There may be light enough to read a menu but not enough to read the
10timetable beside it. Someone waiting for transport can see plenty of places to
11spend money and very few places simply to wait. We have made a peculiar bargain
12when comfort is available only with a receipt.
13It is easy to answer that people should plan better. Take an earlier train.
14Arrange a lift. Carry a phone. Each suggestion may help an individual, but
15together they quietly move every responsibility away from the place itself. A
16cancelled service is not corrected by a fully charged battery. Nor can every
17late worker choose when a shift finishes. Planning matters; so does recognising
18that some journeys are shaped by decisions their passengers did not make.
19A useful town after dark need not resemble a festival. Most people waiting for a
20bus are not asking for entertainment. They want a readable sign, somewhere dry
21to stand and a route home that does not turn the last ten minutes into a puzzle.
22Small provisions can have a dignity that grand projects lack. A working light
23above an ordinary doorway may offer more practical welcome than an illuminated
24slogan announcing how much a town values its community.
25Our language gives the problem away. We call the shops the heart of a town, as
26though the heart could be switched off with the tills. But a place has other
27pulses: footsteps on a pavement, a bus turning the corner, a cleaner locking a
28side entrance. After dark these quieter rhythms become easier to hear. They
29remind us that a town is not a shop window. It is a shared room, and some of its
30occupants come home later than others.
31There are difficult choices. Lighting, maintenance and transport cost money, and
32an unattended building cannot simply be left open without thought. A damaged
33shelter helps nobody. Those limits deserve honest discussion rather than a
34promise that every facility can stay available all night. But limits should
35begin a practical conversation, not end it. Listening to the people who travel
36after the rush hour would reveal which changes are useful and which merely look
37impressive in a photograph.
38That conversation should include people whose journeys are easily overlooked.
39The person using a walking frame may need a seat; the person carrying shopping
40may need a clear route; the worker finishing late may need accurate information
41about the last service. Their needs differ, and no single improvement will
42answer all of them. Asking, observing and checking again would be a better start
43than imagining one convenient traveller and arranging the entire town around
44that imaginary person's timetable.
45We often judge a place at its busiest, in daylight, when the doors are open and
46the photographs are taken. We should sometimes judge it at the edge of its
47working day. What does it offer the person who has finished serving everyone
48else? A town earns its welcome in the ordinary details it leaves available when
49the welcome signs have gone dark. The question is not whether people can stay
50out later for pleasure. It is whether those already out can get home with
51dignity.
Source B
Charles Dickens describes walking through London at night when he was unable to sleep.
1Some years ago, a temporary inability to sleep, referable to a distressing
2impression, caused me to walk about the streets all night, for a series of
3several nights. The disorder might have taken a long time to conquer, if it had
4been faintly experimented on in bed; but, it was soon defeated by the brisk
5treatment of getting up directly after lying down, and going out, and coming
6home tired at sunrise.
7In the course of those nights, I finished my education in a fair amateur
8experience of houselessness. My principal object being to get through the night,
9the pursuit of it brought me into sympathetic relations with people who have no
10other object every night in the year.
11The month was March, and the weather damp, cloudy, and cold. The sun not rising
12before half-past five, the night perspective looked sufficiently long at
13half-past twelve: which was about my time for confronting it.
14The restlessness of a great city, and the way in which it tumbles and tosses
15before it can get to sleep, formed one of the first entertainments offered to
16the contemplation of us houseless people. It lasted about two hours. We lost a
17great deal of companionship when the late public-houses turned their lamps out,
18and when the potmen thrust the last brawling drunkards into the street; but
19stray vehicles and stray people were left us, after that. If we were very lucky,
20a policeman's rattle sprang and a fray turned up; but, in general, surprisingly
21little of this diversion was provided. Except in the Haymarket, which is the
22worst kept part of London, and about Kent-street in the Borough, and along a
23portion of the line of the Old Kent-road, the peace was seldom violently broken.
24But, it was always the case that London, as if in imitation of individual
25citizens belonging to it, had expiring fits and starts of restlessness. After
26all seemed quiet, if one cab rattled by, half-a-dozen would surely follow; and
27Houselessness even observed that intoxicated people appeared to be magnetically
28attracted towards each other; so that we knew when we saw one drunken object
29staggering against the shutters of a shop, that another drunken object would
30stagger up before five minutes were out, to fraternise or fight with it. When we
31made a divergence from the regular species of drunkard, the thin-armed,
32puff-faced, leaden-lipped gin-drinker, and encountered a rarer specimen of a
33more decent appearance, fifty to one but that specimen was dressed in soiled
34mourning. As the street experience in the night, so the street experience in the
35day; the common folk who come unexpectedly into a little property, come
36unexpectedly into a deal of liquor.
37At length these flickering sparks would die away, worn out--the last veritable
38sparks of waking life trailed from some late pieman or hot-potato man--and
39London would sink to rest. And then the yearning of the houseless mind would be
40for any sign of company, any lighted place, any movement, anything suggestive of
41any one being up--nay, even so much as awake, for the houseless eye looked out
42for lights in windows.
Question 01 [4 marks]
Read again the first part of Source A, from lines 1 to 12.
Choose four statements below which are true.
Shade the circles inside the boxes beside the statements you think are true.
Select a maximum of four statements.
Cross out the whole box if you make a mistake.
To restore a statement you crossed out, draw a circle around that box.
A. Some people are still working after shops close.
B. The writer says everybody should stay at home after dark.
C. A worker is waiting for a bus.
D. The writer believes a shutter can end people’s needs.
E. Public toilets may be locked.
F. Every transport shelter has been removed.
G. There may be too little light to read a timetable.
H. The writer says waiting always costs nothing.
Question 02 [8 marks]
You need to refer to Source A and Source B for this question.
Both sources describe being in a town or city at night.
What can you infer about the differences between the experiences of people outdoors at night in Source A and Source B?
Question 03 [12 marks]
You now need to refer only to Source A, from lines 25 to 30.
How does the writer use language to present the town as a living community?
Question 04 [16 marks]
For this question, you need to refer to the whole of Source A together with the whole of Source B.
Compare how the writers convey their different feelings and perspectives about town or city life at night.
In your answer, you could:
compare their different feelings and perspectives
comment on the methods the writers use to convey their feelings and perspectives
support your response with references to both texts.
Question 05 [40 marks]
“Public spaces should serve people after the shops close, not just while they are spending money.”
Write a letter to your local council in which you argue your point of view on this statement.
Marking guidance
Question 1
Correct statements: A, C, E, G. Award one mark for each correct selection.
For this practice paper, if more than four boxes remain selected, subtract one mark for each selection beyond four from the number of correct selections, with a minimum of zero. For example, four correct selections among five selected boxes earns 3 marks.
Question 2
Infer differences rather than simply listing facts: Source A emphasises necessary journeys shaped by shifts and transport, while Dickens chooses to walk because he cannot sleep and learns about those without a home.
Source A’s people may find facilities unavailable despite commercial lighting; Dickens initially finds company in movement and late businesses, then longs for any sign of wakefulness. Support each inference with precise evidence from both sources.
Distinguish the modern writer’s imagined examples and general argument from Dickens’s first-person account. Neither text supports claiming that all people outdoors are homeless or that every traveller feels the same. Apply AO1 inference bands by best fit.
Question 3
The extended metaphor of the heart and other pulses gives the town a life beyond its shops. The counterclaim questions a commercial definition of community.
The three ordinary sounds make late workers and travellers perceptible; quieter rhythms value activity easily overlooked.
The contrast between a shop window and a shared room changes the town from something displayed or sold to a space inhabited together. The final homecoming image supports inclusion. Reward effects, not a count of metaphors; apply AO2 bands for 12 marks.
Question 4
Compare perspectives throughout rather than writing two disconnected summaries. The modern writer argues for practical provision and dignity; Dickens records fascination that develops into sympathetic awareness and a longing for company.
Source A uses hypothetical people, questions, concessions and an extended communal metaphor to make a public argument. Dickens uses first-person witness, a restless-city personification and the shifting experience of Houselessness to make the night feel social and then lonely.
The modern ending measures welcome by what remains available; Dickens’s ending seeks any light or movement. Both value company or provision, but their purposes and narrative positions differ. Credit other supported comparisons; apply AO3 bands for 16 marks.
Question 5
Mark the response as an independent piece of transactional writing addressed to the audience and purpose in the task. There is no required viewpoint and no need to repeat either source.
AO5, 24 marks: assess communication, audience, purpose, register, development and organisation. Indicative bands: 1–6, a simple or fragmentary position with limited development; 7–12, some shaped argument and audience awareness but uneven control; 13–18, clear, developed and persuasive writing with purposeful organisation; 19–24, an assured, engaging argument whose ideas and effects are controlled throughout.
AO6, 16 marks: assess sentences, grammar, punctuation and spelling independently. Indicative bands: 1–4, frequent errors and limited control; 5–8, some accurate patterns with variable security; 9–12, generally secure accuracy and a purposeful range of structures; 13–16, sustained technical control, flexible sentence choices and highly secure accuracy. Occasional slips do not automatically exclude the top band.
Award 0 in either assessment objective if there is no relevant evidence for it. Select a best-fit band and place the response within it. Do not allocate marks by counting techniques, paragraphs or impressive words. These original notes support classroom moderation; they are not an official standardised mark scheme.