examstash

GCSE English Language · Eduqas practice

Lifeboat rescues — letter and review

Component 2 · 2 hours · 80 marks

Question and answer bookletMarking guidance

Source A

A contemporary article considers the people and preparation behind RNLI lifeboat rescues.

A lifeboat rescue may begin with a pager sounding while someone is at work, with
family or asleep. Across the United Kingdom and Ireland, RNLI crews can be
called out at any hour. Most crew members are volunteers. Their readiness is
supported by regular training, both on the water and on land. When a request for
help arrives, the coastguard contacts the station's operations manager or launch
authority; a decision to launch must be made before the crew are paged.
The people who put to sea are only part of that response. Shore crew help to
launch and recover the lifeboat and make it ready for another call. Depending on
the station, preparations can involve opening doors, clearing a slipway or
getting launching equipment ready. Boat crew prepare their protective kit while
others prepare the means of departure. The visible movement towards the water
depends on work that is less likely to appear in a photograph.
Training gives this divided work a common direction. A volunteer must learn more
than the position of a rope or the operation of a piece of equipment. Practice
allows people to develop reliable actions, communicate and understand their
responsibilities. Exercises on shore and afloat are therefore part of
lifesaving, even when nobody is being rescued. The quiet session without a crowd
has value because a later emergency may allow little time for explanation.
Preparation makes cooperation possible.
None of this removes danger. A lifeboat operates in an environment that cannot
be ordered to become calm. Information must be gathered, a crew assembled and a
judgement made about the response. Courage is needed, but courage does not mean
ignoring everything that could go wrong. A decision has consequences for
rescuers as well as for the people waiting for help. The strength of an
organised service lies partly in making responsibility something that is shared
rather than simply admired.
The launch is the sharp edge of a much longer effort. Behind it lie repeated
exercises, checked equipment and tasks completed when the sea has attracted no
headlines. A single successful action can catch the eye; the patient work that
makes it possible slips out of sight. Yet readiness is not a heroic possession
that one person keeps in a pocket. It is a net of dependable actions. Pull away
the unnoticed strands and the impressive moment has less to rest on.
Public recognition often prefers a face to a system. One portrait gives a story
a centre, while a list of roles can seem less memorable. That does not make
individual bravery unimportant. A particular decision may deserve particular
praise. But a rescue described only through its most striking figure leaves
something out. The person aboard the boat belongs to a larger group of people
whose contributions differ in visibility, not necessarily in worth. Recognition
becomes fairer when it can hold both ideas at once.
The work also reaches beyond the station. The RNLI is a charity, and public
support helps provide boats, equipment and training. Those resources connect
people who may never meet. A donation, a training session and a prepared
launching system are different contributions, but all belong to the same
practical purpose. The link is not made by applause alone. It has to be
maintained through the less spectacular business of supporting people and making
sure that a service can continue to respond.
A better account of lifesaving would therefore look at the whole chain, without
pretending that every link does the same job. It would notice the person who
goes to sea and the person who helps bring the boat back. It would leave room
for preparation as well as action, for judgement as well as daring. The most
useful tribute to a rescue team is an understanding of what its members make
possible together. The boat may leave the shore, but the effort that carries it
does not end there.

Source B

In this nineteenth-century biographical account, Grace Darling and her father row towards people stranded after a shipwreck in 1838. A coble is a small fishing boat.

It is said that Grace was the first to seize an oar, and spring into the boat;
but her father, who was a brave man, quickly followed, and the two were soon
working together in harmony. They scarcely spoke at first, William Darling only
giving Grace a few directions with regard to the management of the boat, and
then both used their utmost endeavours to propel her towards the desired spot.
One moment we must linger to look at the heroic girl as she sits firmly in the
boat, with a steady light in her eyes, lips firmly compressed, and strong brave
heart. Could we have seen Grace Darling in more attractive guise? The thunderous
waves were leaping and foaming around the little boat; the dark clouds were
lowering, and the winds blowing furiously. The afrighted sea-birds looked at
them, and screamed shrilly as they saw the boat rocked to and fro, now leaping
on the top of a wave that tossed it high, and now sinking down, down, as if it
were going to the very bottom of the deep. But Grace was not afraid. She
scarcely thought of the danger; for her heart and sympathy were with those who
were on the rock. Long before she got to them, her imagination pictured the
patient faces, full of pain, which would grow bright when they saw her; and as
she thought of them, her arm gained new strength, and she went on again more
energetically than before. Was she, indeed, a girl? Had she sisters, who cried
out if a pain touched them, and who were always helplessly appealing to men for
help? Did she know what fear was? Yes; she knew that she would always be afraid
of her own thoughts, if she did not what she could to rescue the shipwrecked
strangers.
On they went, over the stormy waters, every minute being nearer their goal. The
foam dashed in the face of the intrepid girl, and the salt water made her eyes
smart; but she did not relax her efforts, but kept nobly and steadily at her
work. Her father could not but admire her courage; and the sight of it gave him
even more determination to succeed.
"Are you getting tired, my girl?" he asked presently.
"Not very, father. We shall do it," she replied.
"Yes, I really hope we shall. There they are, poor wretches, glad enough to see
us, I know. It is a good thing it is an ebb tide. If it had not been, we could
not have passed between the islands. It will be flowing when we come back; and
if there are no sailors to help us, we may as well make up our minds to stay on
the rocks with the others, for we shall not be able to get home again."
"Do not let us meet trouble half-way, father; the sailors will be able to help
us."
They pulled hard a little longer, and then contrived to reach the rock on which
the sufferers were waiting.
"Pray, take care, Grace."
"All right, father. Do not be afraid. I will not risk all by my mismanagement."
"If the coble is beaten against the rocks, she will be smashed to pieces."
"I will take care, father. Cannot you land now? See, there is a chance. Now,
father!"
With a tremendous effort, Darling got on the rock, and immediately Grace rowed
the boat back so as to keep her afloat on the water, and free of the dangerous
reefs.

Question 1.1 [3 marks]

Read Source A.

a) Who contacts the station’s operations manager or launch authority when help is needed? [1]

b) Give one job done by shore crew. [1]

c) What kind of organisation is the RNLI? [1]

Question 1.2 [10 marks]

The writer of Source A wants readers to value the less visible work behind lifeboat rescues. How does the writer try to achieve this? Comment on what is said, the use of language, tone and structure, and other ways the writer makes this work seem important. Support your comments with references to the text, using relevant subject terminology where appropriate.

Question 1.3 [3 marks]

Read Source B.

a) Who is said to be the first to seize an oar? [1]

b) Why does William Darling say the ebb tide is helpful? [1]

c) What does Grace do immediately after her father gets onto the rock? [1]

Question 1.4 [10 marks]

A reader said: “Source B presents Grace’s courage as much more than simply being unafraid.” To what extent do you agree? Comment on what is said and how it is said. Support your views with references to the text.

Question 1.5 [4 marks]

Using information from both sources, explain briefly how rescuers work with other people to make a rescue possible. Make clear which source you are referring to.

Question 1.6 [10 marks]

Both texts are about people involved in rescues at sea. Compare the writers’ views of what makes rescuers admirable and how the writers make those views clear to readers. Use references from both texts and make clear which text you are discussing.

Question 2.1 [20 marks]

Your local council is deciding how to recognise people who make an important contribution to the community. Write a letter to the council giving your views about which kinds of contribution deserve recognition and how they should be recognised. Write your letter. Aim to write about 300–400 words.

Question 2.2 [20 marks]

Write a review for a school or college magazine of one of the following: a film, a book, a television programme, or a podcast that you think other students should know about. Write your review. Aim to write about 300–400 words.

Marking guidance

Question 1.1

a) The coastguard.

b) Any one: helping launch the lifeboat; helping recover it; making it ready for another call; preparing doors, slipways or launch equipment.

c) A charity. Award one mark for each part; accurate paraphrases are acceptable.

Question 1.2

The opening connects an emergency with ordinary life and establishes that readiness exists at all hours.

Specific shore duties and training give substance to work readers might overlook.

Contrasts between visible departure and unseen preparation, or a striking action and patient work, challenge a narrow picture of rescue.

The sharp-edge and net imagery makes many small actions seem connected and essential; removing strands implies fragility without them.

The measured acknowledgement of individual bravery makes the argument balanced rather than dismissive.

The widening movement from crew to public donations expands responsibility, before the final chain and carried-effort imagery unites the argument.

Question 1.3

a) Grace Darling.

b) It allows them to pass between the islands.

c) She rows the boat back or keeps it afloat and clear of the reefs. Award one mark per part.

Question 1.4

Any supported degree of agreement is valid.

The writer explicitly says Grace is unafraid, but also locates her courage in sympathy for the stranded people and a sense of moral responsibility.

Imagined suffering motivates greater effort; rhetorical questions challenge assumptions about girls’ helplessness.

Stinging eyes, continued rowing and the father’s admiration show endurance with consequences for another person.

Her reassuring dialogue and quick instructions show practical confidence and concern about safe boat management.

The tide discussion and dangerous reefs complicate any suggestion that bravery removes the need for judgement.

The heroic narrator and reconstructed dialogue strongly shape the reader’s admiration; reward evaluation of this presentation rather than accepting every imagined thought as documented fact.

Question 1.5

Award up to two marks for accurate relevant information from each source, maximum four. No comparison of techniques is required.

Source A: coastguard and launch authority communicate and decide; boat and shore crew carry out different preparations; training supports communication; public support provides boats, equipment and training.

Source B: Grace and her father row together; he supplies directions and knowledge of tides; she encourages him; sailors may be needed for the return; Grace controls the boat while he lands.

Award distinct information rather than repeated versions of the same point.

Question 1.6

Compare throughout or in a clearly connected sequence; a separate account of each source without links is limited.

Source A admires collective readiness, repeated practice, judgement and contributions of unequal visibility; Source B concentrates admiration on Grace’s courage, sympathy and persistence.

Both recognise cooperation, but Source A develops a broad organised network while Source B dramatises a father-and-daughter partnership.

A uses explanatory detail, contrasts and extended images of connected effort; B uses dramatic weather, admiring narration, rhetorical questions and dialogue to centre a heroic figure.

A directly challenges the public preference for a single face; B makes a single courageous girl a memorable centre while retaining her father’s practical role.

Reward nuanced differences and similarities supported by precise textual examples.

Question 2.1

A convincing letter adapts its tone to a council audience and gives developed reasons for its proposals.

The writer may discuss volunteers, teams or individuals, visible or less visible contributions, practical rewards or public acknowledgement. No particular view is required.

Reward specific examples, consideration of competing needs and a purposeful opening and ending. No postal address is required for full marks.

Question 2.2

A successful review selects relevant details, evaluates strengths and weaknesses and guides its intended readers.

Reward a clear judgement supported by specific explanation, rather than a plot summary alone.

The work reviewed may be real or invented. There is no requirement to review a work about rescues or to connect this task to Source A or B.

Reward an engaging magazine voice, organised discussion and an effective recommendation or conclusion.

All practice papers →